Soaps Under $10.00

Thursday, March 16, 2017

Derby Extra

 
 
Over the next few weeks I am going to keep a daily running experience of different blades. Mainly so that I can remember what they were like. Hopefully, you will find this interesting or helpful as you try different blades. Each blade will be used for 7 days unless they are a really bad blade.
 

Blade Name

Derby Extra
Derby Extra
 

 

 

 

 

 
 

Shaving conditions

Beard Type

Light beard growth, thicker on and under the chin, very sensitive on the neck. Susceptible to razor bumps on and under the chin area.

Preshave Prep:

  • Shower
  • Shave Secret (four drops)
  • Mason's Boutique Lillian Shave Soap (Days1-3)
  • Van der Hagen Premium soap Shave Stick (Days 4-7)
  • Lord LP1822L DE Razor
  • Soft water
  • Maggard 22mm knot synthetic brush

Post Shave:

  • Dickenson's Witch Hazel (Blue Bottle)
  • Pinaud Clubman Original
  • Nivea Balm for Sensitive Skin

The Shave Week

Day 1 Shave

  • Smoothness: Smooth, sharp shave 1st pass was fairly close, but not as close as other blades.
  • Tugging: No tugging on the neck area
  • Razor Burn: Slight razor burn that lasted on a couple of minutes.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Nice, and close shave that was comfortable.

Day 2 Shave

  • Smoothness: Not quite as smooth as yesterday. the shave cream was not a thick and creamy as yesterday and that may have played a part.
  • Tugging: Slight tugging on the chin area but the neck area where I am most sensitive, was problem free.
  • Razor Burn: A little more razor burn than the day before. Seems like I had to buff more to get a closer shave and that irritated the skin.
  • Nicks: No Nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Close in some areas but obvious misses that had to be touched up.

Day 3 Shave

  • Smoothness: Slightly less smooth. I could feel some tugging on the cheeks which is unusual.
  • Tugging: A little tugging on the chin area, but non on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: More razor burn than the day before. Had to do more buffing to get a closer shave. Buffing seems to irritate and damage the skin more.
  • Nicks: One nick between the lower lip and chin.
  • Closeness: Closeness seems to be diminishing with this blade. Tomorrow I am going to change back to the VDH Luxury soap and see if that improves the chave. 

Day 4 Shave

  • Smoothness: Blade was still pretty smooth, but It did struggle in some places where the growth was a little thicker.
  • Tugging: There was a little tugging on the neck area when I shaved against the grain.
  • Razor Burn: More razor burn was detected than last night. Besides the chin area, there was some under the jaw line.
  • Nicks: Two weepers and one nick that was due to my own carelessness.
  • Closeness: it was a close shave but I had to work at it. Where some blades would get it this blade seemed to pass over it. It was a good shave but not as comfortable as when the blade was new.

Day 5 Shave

  • Smoothness: Smoothness has dropped off significantly. This shave has felt rough and my skin has felt some soreness after the shave.
  • Tugging: Tugging has increased especially on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: More razor burn has been felt after this shave. I has also noticed the skin to feel bumpy and slightly swollen along with some skin damage.
  • Nicks: There were no nicks with this shave.
  • Closeness: The shave felt close in some places and in others it felt like it missed the stubble all together.

Day 6 Shave

  • Smoothness: The smoothness really dropped off with this shave. I could feel noticeable tugging all over and lots of stubble still visible and could be felt. The shave was patchy all over and there was a very low comfort level. After the shave, It felt like my skin was "grooved" and ragged feeling along with a dry tight feeling.
  • Tugging: The tugging has increased some more and was very unpleasant on the sensitive areas.
  • Razor Burn: Really bad razor burn all over my face. This lasted more than an hour and was uncomfortable. I had to go back and reapply a skin cream trying to get it to feel comfortable.
  • Nicks: There were no nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Not close at all. The shave felt rough and patchy, and the skin felt bumpy and swollen.

 Concluding Thoughts and Score

This was an interesting blade. Loaded in the Lord L6 razor, it began with a nice shave, but quickly deteriorated over the next few days. It felt like the smooth coating pealed off and I was shaving on the stainless blade. What I disliked about the blade was the amount of razor burn and the bumpy feeling it left my face with. I really should have stopped after the fourth  shave, but I didn't and feel like I made a bad decision with that.

A very cheap blade that I would probably not use for more than two or three shaves. Considering this, I would opt out for a more expensive blade that wears down in a more smoother fashion that doesn't leave my skin feeling sore, burnt and patchy feeling. After this shave I am going to have to take a few days off with a good smooth blade and a sensitive cream to let my skin recover.
   
If I were to score this blade form 1 to 10 I would rate it an overall 4.4.
  • Sharpness: 6
  • Smoothness: 4
  • Tugging: 5
  • Razor Burn:3
  • Closeness: 4
  • Overall: 4.4

Monday, March 13, 2017

Shark Super Stainless

 
 
Over the next few weeks I am going to keep a daily running experience of different blades. Mainly so that I can remember what they were like. Hopefully, you will find this interesting or helpful as you try different blades. Each blade will be used for 7 days unless they are a really bad blade.
 

Blade Name

Shark Super Stainless Blade  
Shark Super Stainless Blade
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Shaving conditions

I changed things up a bit this week. Monday I had used the normal shave prep but changed the routine for the rest of the week. I received and started using Stirling "Barbershop" soap and changed to my Lord DE razor which is a little more aggressive. for the remainder of the week

Beard Type

Light beard growth, thicker on and under the chin, very sensitive on the neck. Susceptible to razor bumps on and under the chin area.

Preshave Prep:

 
  • Shower
  • Shave Secret (four drops) - Day 1 only
  • The well Dressed Guy Pre-shave Oil - Days 2-7
  • Van der Hagen Premium soap (Shave Stick) - Day 1 then day3 3-7
  • Stirling Soaps - Barbershop - Day 2
  • Merkur Classic razor - Day 1 only
  • Lord LP1822L DE Razor - Days 2-7
  • Soft water
  • Maggard 22mm knot synthetic brush

Post Shave:

  • Dickenson's Witch Hazel (Blue Bottle)
  • Pinaud Clubman Original
  • Nivea Balm for Sensitive Skin
 

The Shave Week

Day 1 Shave

  • Smoothness: Blade exhibited the normal sharp feeling that new blades almost always do. The shave was relatively smooth and enjoyable.
  • Tugging: No tugging was experienced on the sensitive neck areas.
  • Razor Burn: Did not experience much razor burn. A little more than normal on the chin area as I normally have to do with the Merkur Classic razor. Aftershave burned a little but only for a few seconds. Nothing to make it uncomfortable.
  • Nicks: There were no nicks or weepers from the shave.
  • Closeness: Closeness was only achieved by excessive buffing on the chin areas and touch-ups on the neck area. I think that I will change razors due to the amount of buffing I am having to. It appears that this razor is just to mild.
 

Day 2 Shave

 
  • Smoothness: Blade was very smooth and sharp. There was an enhanced performance using the Lord DE razor. It is a little more aggressive and seems to hit that sweet spot pretty good.
  • Tugging: No tugging on the neck area where it is very sensitive.
  • Razor Burn: A little razor burn do the razor being a little more aggressive, but felt normal as the aftershave stopped burning within a couple of minutes.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Very close shave! The Stirling shave soap provided a great deal of protection and aftershave comfort. However, having shaved at night, the next morning my face felt like leather. I'm not sure what I did wrong with the soap. I will have to investigate later. For the next few shave, I will go back to the Van Der Hagen Luxury soap.
 

Day 3 Shave

  • Smoothness: Another smooth and close shave without much effort.
  • Tugging: No tugging on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: A little when the aftershave was applied. Stopped after a couple of minutes.
  • Nicks: No Nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Very close and comfortable shave
 

Day 4 Shave

  • Smoothness: Another smooth shave! Today I went back to the VDH Luxury soap. Every shave  With this blade so far has been BBS. 
  • Tugging: A little tugging on the neck but it was not very noticible.
  • Razor Burn: A small amount of burn when thhe aftershave was applied. Again this is on the areas that I tend to buff more than usual.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Very close and smooth shave. This makes four BBS shave in a row.
 

Day 5 Shave

  • Smoothness: It was a little difficult to determine if the smoothness was diminishing any today. I was in a hurry and did a two pass pass mainly against the grain. There were no glaring issues with the blade, but it was under a little heavier load than normal.
  • Tugging: Slight tugging on the neck area, but then it was a two pass shave and it was to be expected.
  • Razor Burn: Slight razor burn that went away after a minute or two.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Shave was close, but not BBS. Better than I was expecting.
 

Day 6 Shave

  • Smoothness: Another smooth shave! The shave soap was a little drier than usual on the first pass but it cut nicely.
  • Tugging: Not much tugging, but I could tell that the blade was loosing it's sharpness. I could feel some tugging on the cheeks but it was not uncomfortable at all.
  • Razor Burn: No razor burn when the aftershave was applied.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Overall, the shave was close, but could feel where the blade just didn't get it all when rubbing my hand against the grain on the face. It was a close shave but not BBS. I was still happy with it and it was comfortable afterwards.

Day 7 Shave

  • Smoothness: another smooth shave! I could tell that the blade was beginning to cut less close this time. It did not effect the smoothness or cause tugging.
  • Tugging: Nice smooth on the neck area without any tugging.
  • Razor Burn: No razor burn when the aftershave was applied.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers
  • Closeness: The shave was close but not BBS. It was still acceptable and only felt a little rough when you rubbed against the grain in some places.

 Concluding Thoughts and Score

 
The Shark Stainless steal blade has given a weeks worth of smooth and comfortably close shaves. I believe I could have got a few more days out of it if I were to push it. This blade is one that I will keep in my rotation of blades. Smooth and comfortable with the Lord L6 razor and VDH Luxury soap.
 
If I were to score this blade form 1 to 10 I would rate it an overall 9.4.
  • Sharpness: 9
  • Smoothness: 10
  • Tugging: 10
  • Razor Burn: 10
  • Closeness: 8
  • Overall: 9.4

Thursday, March 2, 2017

Lord Super Stainless



Over the next few weeks I am going to keep a daily running experience of different blades. Mainly so that I can remember what they were like. Hopefully, you will find this interesting or helpful as you try different blades. Each blade will be used for 7 days unless they are a really bad blade.
 

Blade Name


Lord Super Stainless

Lord Super Stainless








Shaving conditions


Beard Type

Light beard growth, thicker on and under the chin, very sensitive on the neck. Susceptible to razor bumps on and under the chin area.

Preshave Prep:

  • Shower
  • The Well Groomed Guy Pre-Shave Oil
  • Van der Hagen Premium soap (Shave Stick)
  • Merkur Classic razor
  • Soft water
  • Maggard 22mm knot synthetic brush

Post Shave:

  • Dickenson's Witch Hazel (Blue Bottle)
  • Pinaud Clubman Original
  • Nivea Balm for Sensitive Skin

The Shave Week

Day 1 Shave

  • Smoothness: Sharpness could be felt but was not uncomfortable. The cut from the blade was smooth and non irritating.
  • Tugging; There was no tugging on the sensitive neck areas.
  • Razor Burn: Just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing.
  • Nicks: There were no nicks or weepers
  • Closeness: Shave was very close and the feel was smooth an hour later. after 10hrs, there was just a hint for growth coming back.

Day 2 Shave

  • Smoothness: Sharpness seemed to diminish some. The edge could not be felt. This is common with all blades. The shave was smooth and non irritating from the blade cut.
  • Tugging: There was no tugging on the sensitive neck areas.
  • Razor Burn: Again there was just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing. This was noticeable when the aftershave was applied. It lasted only a few seconds.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Another smooth shave that was close with very little irritation.

Day 3 Shave

  • Smoothness: Blade seemed a little duller as it seemed to bounce on the chin area. Otherwise the shave was smooth and comfortable again for the third day.
  • Tugging: Just a slight hint of tugging on the sensitive neck area.
  • Razor Burn: Again there was just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing. This was noticeable when the aftershave was applied. It lasted only a few seconds.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Another smooth shave that was close with very little irritation.

Day 4 Shave

  • Smoothness: Blade didn't seem to have the bounce feel to it tonight. It cut smoothly and comfortably. The thicker growth areas did require a little buffing but it continued to be a comfortable shave.
  • Tugging: Just a hint of tugging on one sensitive area of my neck. It seemed to be a little worse than the night before. However it did not create any skin related problems.
  • Razor Burn: Again there was just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing. This was noticeable when the aftershave was applied. It lasted only a few seconds.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Another smooth shave that was close with very little irritation.

Day 5 Shave

  • Smoothness: Another smooth shave. Blade still seemed relatively sharp. I was in a hurry and did minor buffing on the chin area.
  • Tugging: Again,  just a slight hint of tugging on the sensitive neck area. 
  • Razor Burn: Again there was just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing. This was noticeable when the aftershave was applied. It lasted only a few seconds.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness:  Another smooth shave that was close with very little irritation. Pretty much an identical shave as last night.

Day 6 Shave

  • Smoothness: Again I was in a hurry but I still had a smooth shave. Blade still seemed relatively sharp but noticeable tugging is beginning. I was in a hurry and did minor buffing on the chin area.
  • Tugging: Tugging was minimal. Instead of using a thin, watery lather for the final pass to get slickness, I opted for a thicker and more dense lather. I think this provided more protection for a closer less painful ATG shave.
  • Razor Burn: Again there was just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing. This was noticeable when the aftershave was applied. It lasted only a few seconds.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Considering I was in a hurry, I did get a close shave and almost a BBS. I could have achieved that if I took a little more time. I do think that thinker, denser lather on all passes works better than thinning it out. using a shave stick, I achieved the thickness by not wetting the face between lathers.

Day 7 Shave

  • Smoothness: After seven days, the blade loosing it's smoothness. It became more difficult to cut the growth and bet a clean pass. The ATG pass was more difficult.
  • Tugging: The tugging on the neck area was more noticible tonight. I think that this is this blades last day.
  • Razor Burn: Again there was just a slight razor burn on the areas where I did extra buffing. This was noticeable when the aftershave was applied. It lasted only a few seconds.
  • Nicks: Another day with no nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: I just didn't get a very close shave this evening. About an hour after the shave when the skin should have settled down,  It was not close. It appeared acceptable, but it did not feel close or comfortable.

 Concluding Thoughts and Score

This blade is a non coated stainless steel blade. It has proven to be a nice comfortable blade that Iwill most certainly be using over again. It is very smooth and gave me weeks worth of shaves without any problems. A sharp blade that is smooth but tends to have a little ATG tugging  on the sixth and seventh shave. This can be overcome by Soap density. This blade will definitely be in my rotation.

If I were to score this blade form 1 to 10 I would rate it an overall 9.
  • Sharpness: 9
  • Smoothness: 10
  • Tugging: 9
  • Razor Burn: 8
  • Closeness: 9
  • Overall: 9

Thursday, February 23, 2017

Baili Super Blue Blades



Over the next few weeks I am going to keep a daily running experience of different blades. Mainly so that I can remember what they were like. Hopefully, you will find this interesting or helpful as you try different blades. Each blade will be used for 7 days unless they are a really bad blade.
 

Blade Name

Baili Super Blue Razors - High Quality Platinum Coated, Super Stainless Steel Blades.









Shaving conditions

Beard Type

Light beard growth, thicker on and under the chin, very sensitive on the neck. Susceptible to razor bumps on and under the chin area.

Preshave Prep:

  • Shower
  • Shave Secret (four drops)
  • Van der Hagen Premium soap (Shave Stick)
  • Merkur Classic razor
  • Soft water
  • Maggard 22mm knot synthetic brush

Post Shave:

  • Dickenson's Witch Hazel (Blue Bottle)
  • Pinaud Clubman Original
  • Nivea Balm for Sensitive Skin

The Shave Week

Day 1 Shave

  • Smoothness: Very smooth blade and not excessively sharp.
  • Tugging: No noticeable tugging when going against the grin on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: Very little razor burn. lasted just a few seconds when the aftershave was applied..
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Shave felt good but lacked a total BBS. I could still feel some stubble when rubbing against the grain in the trouble areas. It was a very comfortable shave and felt very nice afterward. 

Day 2 Shave

  • Smoothness: Smoothness was still good but the sharpness seemed to have dropped off just a little bit. However it still cut nicely.
  • Tugging: There was no noticeable tugging when going against the grain on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: Again, very little razor burn when aftershave was applied. Skin showed no visible signs of razor bumps or redness.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Another very comfortable shave! Not quite a BBS but there was no soreness, and the feel was smooth. Again a little stubble when rubbed against the grain in the problem areas.

Day 3 Shave

  • Smoothness: Blade continues to be very smooth although it is definitely showing signs of loosing it's sharpness. First pass does not remove as much stubble as it did on its first shave.
  • Tugging: No tugging on my sensitive neck area.
  • Razor Burn: Mild razor burn on and around the chin area where there is the heaviest growth.
  • Nicks: One small weeper on the neck that closed off when the cold water was applied.
  • Closeness: Not as close as the previous shaves, but still acceptable

Day 4 Shave

  • Smoothness: Smoothness is still there, but I think this is due to the fact that the blade is becoming more dull.
  • Tugging: No noticeable tugging, but I could detect that is beginning to do so on the neck area. I was having to stretch the skin to adjust to the blade wanting to tug a little.
  • Razor Burn: More noticeable razor burn. I think this is due to excessive buffing on the chin area and under the chin to get the stubble off.
  • Nicks: Again no nicks.
  • Closeness: I have lost the closeness of the shave. It took a lot of buffing to get the stubble down to an acceptable level. After the shave I could still see places where the blade seemed to just roll over the stray growth and left it visible. The chin started to show signs of bumps from excessive buffing to get the strays. 10 hours later I could feel the growth coming back quickly and a little soreness setting in.

 Concluding Thoughts and Score

I decided to stop using this blade after the fourth shave. It was beginning to take to long in chasing the strays and the pickups were not doing well. A smooth blade but it lost its sharpness quickly. This blade might work a little better in a more aggressive razor, but I think there would have been more weepers towards the end of it's sharpness life. Those with a more course beard may find this blade inadequate for their needs. I would suggest this blade if you are experiencing bad razor burn or ingrown hair to allow your skin to recover. Not a great blade, but one that I would buy and use again, but not in large quantities.

If I were to score this blade form 1 to 10 I would rate it an overall 7.
  • Sharpness: 5
  • Smoothness: 10
  • Tugging: 10
  • Razor Burn: 8
  • Closeness: 4
  • Overall: 7
 

Friday, February 17, 2017

Dorco ST300


Over the next few weeks I am going to keep a daily running experience of different blades. Mainly so that I can remember what they were like. Hopefully, you will find this interesting or helpful as you try different blades. Each blade will be used for 7 days unless they are a really bad blade.

Dorco ST300


Dorco ST300
All Dorco blades are micro grinded and coated to provide a smooth, clean shave. This double-edged razor blade offers the most convenient shave at a reasonable price. Made in Vietnam.




Shaving conditions:


Beard Type

Light beard growth, thicker on and under the chin, very sensitive on the neck. Susceptible to razor bumps on and under the chin area.

Preshave Prep:

  • Shower
  • Shave Secret (four drops)
  • Van der Hagen Premium soap or deluxe soap melted into a shave stick.
  • Merkur Classic razor
  • Soft water
  • Maggard 22mm knot synthetic brush

Post Shave:

  • Dickenson's Witch Hazel (Blue Bottle)
  • Pinaud Clubman Original
  • Nivea Balm for Sensitive Skin

The Shave Week


Day 1 Shave

  • Smoothness: Average smoothness. The blade felt sharp at the start of the shave, but seemed to loose that sharp feeling toward the end of the shave.
  • Tugging: A small amount of tugging on the neck area, but not enough to cause weepers or bumps.
  • Razor Burn: Some razor burn on the chin and neck area but diminished after about an hour.
  • Nicks: No nicks or weepers.
  • Closeness: Shave was not BBS. I had to do quite a bit of buffing on the chin area to get a close shave. After the shave and the skin settled down, I could feel a slight noticeable amount of stubble on the cheeks and visible stubble on the chin. After ten hours, I noticed a shadow appearing and noticeable stubble all over the face and neck.

Day 2 Shave

Change the blade over to my Maggard MR1 razor for a little more aggressive shave for the rest of the week.
  • Smoothness: Noticeably sharper blade exposure. Tugging on the neck area increase resulting in a couple of small weepers and more razor burn. Sharpness was still fairly good for the second shave but noticeably duller due to more buffing on the chin area.
  • Tugging: More noticeable tugging on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: There was more razor burn present on the second shave compared to the first. I attribute this to the more aggressive razor.
  • Nicks: Several small weepers that healed by themselves. A lot of tiny weepers on the front of the chin below the corners of the lips. This area is difficult to shave clean if the razor is dull and produces a lot of little weepers if buffed to much to get a close shave.
  • Closeness: After about an hour, the skin felt smooth on the cheeks and neck area, but noticeable stubble could be felt. The chin area still showed stubble that did not cut cleanly and chin area at the lower corners of the mouth was still bumpy, sore and noticible razor bumps were beginning to form.

Day 3 Shave

  • Smoothness: The blade felt sharp and ragged. Not smooth at all. My skin felt tender and trying to get a close shave was very painful.
  • Tugging: A lot of tugging on the neck area that was painful and produced  several weepers.
  • Razor Burn: The razor burn had increased a lot since the last shave
  • Nicks: Several weepers on the nick and chin area.
  • Closeness: Not close at all. After the shave noticeable stubble was left behind on the chin. The only smooth part of my face were my cheeks. Noticeable razor bumps were appearing on the jaw line by the chin.

 Concluding Thoughts and Score

I had to stop using this blade after three shaves. It was a matter of self preservation.  In my opinion it is not a good blade for tender skin and I could not obtain the closeness I like without damage to the skin. Lots of weepers, stubble and painful skin. I just do not like the way my skin hurt after just three shaves.I doubt very seriously if I will try the ST301 blades that I have.

After these three shaves, I am going to have to go back to the Merkur Classic with the Voskhad blade and eliminate the ATG passes for a while. At least until I heal up.

If I were to score this blade form 1 to 10 I would rate it an overall 4.
  • Sharpness: 5
  • Smoothness: 2
  • Tugging: 3
  • Razor Burn: 3
  • Closeness: 3
  • Overall: 4

Monday, February 13, 2017

A San Antonio Shave



This past week me and the wife went to the TMEA convention in San Antonio (Texas Music Educators Convention.) As always, the downtown area was beautiful and with the hotel on the river walk, well, who could ask for more. I really like these conventions because it gives me an opportunity to hear the All State bands and Orchestras practice and perform. It's really amazing what high school kids can do with music! We also attended several clinics, browsed the exhibits and enjoy great Mexican food.

Shaving, however, is a different story. San Antonio has nice hard water. My first shave told me that the water out of the tap does not lubricate as nicely as my soft water back home. It tends to cause the razor to drag and doesn't interact with the soap very well. I had packed Van Der Hagan Luxury soap for the trip and face lathering was a little more difficult. The lather produced was not well developed and did not offer much lubrication for the shave. I also think that the Merkur Classic razor with a Voskhod blade were not good choices. I think something a little more aggressive and sharper would have done a better job.


Well Groomed Guy
Packing a pre-shave oil was a good idea. I almost made a mistake when I first chose the Shave Secret oil.  Second guessing myself I packed my Pre Shave Oil For Gentlemen made by The Well Groomed Guy. This actually helped some with the lubrication problem. It absolutely helped with the after shave feel and razor burn.


I think next time I go back to San Antonio, I will need to do more research with hard water problems and be better prepared to pack for it.


Wednesday, February 8, 2017

Blade Review - Wilkinson Sword Classic

Over the next few weeks I am going to keep a daily running experience of different blades. Mainly so that I can remember what they were like. Hopefully, you will find this interesting or helpful as you try different blades. Each blade will be used for 7 days unless they are a really bad blade.

Wilkinson Sword Classic (Black Box)

Wilkinson Sword Classic
Wilkinson blades are stainless steel blades that are triple coated to produce a blade that is sharp, long lasting and smooth. Combinations that all DE shavers want out of their blades. The Manufacturer says:
"Wilkinson Sword Classic Double Edge Razor Blades has been improved by Wilkinson's famous triple coating process of chromium to resist corrosion, ceramic for added durability, and PTFE for less irritation"



Shaving conditions


Beard Type

Light beard growth, thicker on and under the chin, very sensitive on the neck. Susceptible to razor bumps on and under the chin area.

Preshave Prep:

  • Shower
  • Shave Secret (four drops)
  • Van der Hagen Premium soap and Deluxe soap ( melted into a shave stick)
  • Merkur Classic razor
  • Soft water
  • Maggard 22mm knot synthetic brush

Post Shave:

  • Dickenson's Witch Hazel (Blue Bottle)
  • Pinaud Clubman Original
  • Nivea Balm for Sensitive Skin

The Shave Week


Day 1 Shave

  • Smoothness: Very smooth. Without the feeling of coarseness. Did not take away from the sharpness of the blade. Very good first use smoothness.
  • Tugging: No tugging detected as I went against the grain on the neck area. This is my most tender part of the shave.
  • Razor Burn: No noticeable razor burn when aftershave was applied.
  • Nicks: Four little weepers. Two on the neck and two on the chin. Didn't realize I had them until after the shave was over. Very minor.
  • Closeness: Very close shave in most areas. I went easy on the chin. Having just used a Voskhod for a week I was reluctant to do much buffing for a close shave. Two or three touch-up areas.
  • 10 Hours Later: Still looks and feels good. What growth has come back is barely noticeable to the feel, however it was visibly noticeable on the chin area

Day 2 Shave

  • Smoothness: Smoothness was still noticeable though the sharpness seemed to be diminished a bit.
  • Tugging: Just a little bit of minor tugging on the neck area.
  • Razor Burn: A little bit of razor burn on the jaw line and chin areas. I w
    as shaving pretty fast as I didn't have a lot of time.
  • Nicks: A couple of weepers on the chin and one small cut on the jaw line. This cut was due to my own mistake by being hasty.
  • Closeness: Tonights shave was not a close shave. I could see where the chin area was not close even though I buffed after three against the grain passes. About an hour after the shave, I could feel stubble in various places all over my face as well as a little skin soreness. I also noticed where the blade had chaffed areas of the skin causing roughness and discomfort. Not a good shave tonight. If I get similar results the next night, I will call it quits with this blade and give my skin time to heal before I try my next blade.

Day 3 Shave

  • Smoothness: The blade seemed to be less sharp and a little smoother. It seems to shave with a little more comfort if the soap is thinner and not as thick.  With this in mind I will continue through the week with the blade.
  • Tugging: Slight tugging on neck area. This may be due to the fact that my skin has been irritated some from the blade and it's tenderness is more aggravated by the sharp blade.
  • Razor Burn: Some razor burn on the chin area. Hours after the shave, the skin feels slightly "raw" and not comfortable to the hand.
  • Nicks: A couple of nicks on the chin and lower lip area.
  • Closeness: Much closer than yesterday's shave. This blade likes the soap to be slicker for a smoother shave. However the blades does tend to irritate the skin where it feels sore.
  • 10 Hours Later: Normal stubble regrowth, skin tenderness.

Day 4 Shave

  • Smoothness: The blade continues to be smooth. Sharpness on the other hand is strangely yes and no. It is sharp enough the smooth both the cheeks, but I just can't get a close shave on the chin area.
  • Tugging: The tugging on the neck area seems to have increased some. It is not uncomfortable but the feel of the blade reminds me to be careful. It just feels like a rough sharpness.
  • Razor Burn: Got plenty of razor burn on the chin and upper neck area. More than likely it is caused by me trying to get the blade to produce a smooth cut.
  • Nicks; No nicks or weepers this shave.
  • Closeness: Not a close shave. It seems like this blade started off with promise, but continued to fail each day in delivering a smooth shave.

 Concluding Thoughts and Score

After four shaves, I have decided to call it quites. This particular blade just did not delivery a close shave. When it produced the best cut, it also produced a lot of weepers. Somewhat happy after the first shave. Close, no tugging and no razor burn. Exactly what I am looking for. However it just didn't seem to give them the feeling of comfort and satisfaction I look for in a shave. It may be that blade sharpness and my sensitive skin do not work well together.The blade likes a slicker maybe thinner soap. After four days and continued razor burn, I have decided to finish the week off with the Voskhod and let my skin heal and settle down before I try another blade.

If I were to score this blade form 1 to 10 I would give it:
  •  Sharpness 8
  • Smoothness 6
  • Tugging 7
  • Razor Burn: 4
  • Closeness: 5
  • Overall: 6